The congruence of quality values in higher education.

Telford, Archibald Ronald (2002) The congruence of quality values in higher education. PhD thesis, Edinburgh Napier University.

Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial.

Download (21MB)


Higher education and more specifically University education is being called to account
more and more. It follows therefore that the Universities must present information on the
quality of service which they provide as perceived by their customers and their supporters
who supply their funding.
In this thesisr esearchi s reported on the measuremenot f the quality valuesw hich Students,
Lecturing Staff, and Senior Management display within the period of a leaming
programme. The principal aim was to ascertain through hypothesis testing if the level of
congruence of the value systems of these three main contributors to the learning experience
influenced the degree of satisfaction of the Students as the customers and to develope a
framework for measuring contributor's quality values.
Theseo bjectivesw ere researchedin stagesa s follows;
The first stage was an extensive literature review which was used to underpin the ainis and
objectiveso f the researchb y establishinga n understandingo f the relationshipsb etween
Culture and Values, Quality, and Service. The Service review focused upon Higher
Education in the University environment including such aspects quality and culture, values
and the determinantso f servicqq uality, customerf ocus and society's role within the
educatione xperience,s takeholderp ositioning within the educationp rocess,f inancial
considerationsm, easuremenot f satisfactiona nd dissatisfaction,a nd studentt ransformation
in terms of their educatione xperience.T he review revealeda numbero f weaknessesin
existing knowledge primarily that there has been little research undertaken into the
measuremenot f more than two parties within an educationt ransactiona nd how the
involvement of more than two parties within such is perceived in relation to customer
The second stage of the research was a Case Study using a mixed method approach which
comprised interview techniques from which a framework for measuring quality in higher
education was developed, and a questionnaire survey undertaken which was used to test
the framework from which a number of conclusions were drawn.
The Case Study was conducted within the Business School of the Napier University of
Edinburgh. Using qualitative and quantitative methodologies the study examined the
expectations as prescribed by the Importance which Senior Management, Lecturing Staff,
and Students placed upon aspects of their learning programme. Additionally Students were
asked their perceived levels of Satisfaction with their programmes. The outcomes of
the Case Study were analysed using triangulated methods and used to highlight any
problem aspects within programmes. These aspects were then subjected to value analysis to
test the effects of congruity of stakeholder values on the levels of customer satisfaction.
The findings of the case study were that, during the period of the research, the degree of
congruenceo f the three main stakeholdersh ad no impact upon the levelso f satisfactiono f
the Students as customers of the learning programme as offered by the Business School.
Further analysis of the Case Study findings indicated the following :
1) That significant core value Gaps between the levels of Student Importance and
Satisfaction exist within certain aspects of their learning experience more particularly
during the later period of their learning programme.
2) That the role of Senior Management within the learning programme seems to have little
influence upon the Student level of satisfaction.
3) That communication channels between Lecturers and Senior Management on policies
within the learning programme appear to need reappraisal.
4) That significant differences in core values of Importance exist between Lecturers and
5) That Student importance levels and by definition their value systems changed over the
period of their learning programme.
6) That there were non-core value significant differences in the importance which Full-time
and Part-time Studentsp lacedu pon certain aspectso f their progranu-neo f learning
7) That there were non-core value significant differences in the importance which
Undergraduatea nd GraduateS tudentsp lacedu pon certain aspectso f their programmeo f
8) That there were non-core value significant differences in the importance which
Undergraduatea nd Lecturersp lacedu pon a programmeo f learningy ear on year.
The size and distribution of the populations sampled has enabled conclusions to be drawn
on the validity and generalisabilityo f the framework for measuringq uality valuesi n the
field of higher education throughout the Napier University and to some extent when factors
such as cross cultural values,d emographicc onsiderationsq, uestionnaire'sw ording, etc.,
are taken into account as the basis for the further examination of stakeholder value systems
within the education experience in the UK and internationally.

Item Type: Thesis (PhD)
Uncontrolled Keywords: Higher education; quality of service; student experience; value systems; students; lecturing staff; senior management; stakeholders;
University Divisions/Research Centres: The Business School > School of Accounting, Economics and Statistics
Dewey Decimal Subjects: 300 Social sciences > 370 Education > 378 Higher education
Library of Congress Subjects: L Education > LB Theory and practice of education > LB2300 Higher Education
Item ID: 4279
Depositing User: Mrs Lyn Gibson
Date Deposited: 11 Mar 2011 10:50
Last Modified: 27 Jul 2011 15:44

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

Edinburgh Napier University is a registered Scottish charity. Registration number SC018373